Oh, cool! A survey...
I had to admit that I am torn between SuperTape and Walker's No Shine tape. Here's why:
Since I am from Arizona, we have crystal clear, blue skies that are brilliantly light nearly all year long. Due to this, tape shine tends to be a problem for me. Here's my thoughts:
1) SuperTape is wonderful, but shines in the front. It's easy to clean up (with the mirror slide) and is very user-friendly for absolute beginners. If one has bangs in the front, or chooses to scallop their tape in the front (with scissors), SuperTape is an awesome choice. Yet, if one was to comb their hair back, they might find it to not be the best solution due to potential shine.
2) Walker's no shine tape is great and the shine is slight at best. I absolutely love this tape, but there are some surprising draw backs to it too. In Arizona, most of the year, we have very low humidity levels. However, this last month, during our monsoon season, I had real issues with trying to keep it from bubbling and wrinkling on my scalp. For some reason, I doesn't seem to like Arizona's hot temps (110+) and higher humidity during August.
I would recommend having a nice collection of both tapes, just in case one needs it. Just my thoughts!
"Uh, oh - Is my hair on backwards??"